Black Return
Trap Normal

Black Return

  • Archetype:
  • Blackwing

  • View:
  • 3302




When exactly 1 "Blackwing" monster (and no other monster) is Special Summoned: Target 1 face-up monster your opponent controls; gain LP equal to the ATK of that target, and if you do, return it to the hand.




 
 
AI Power Analysis
Removal / NegationConfidence: MediumEvaluated Oct 8, 2026
48± 8/ 100
Power Score
Intrinsic 46
Deck 50

Black Return — Power Evaluation

Final Score: 48 ± 8 · Confidence: Medium

  • Intrinsic: 45.6 · Deck: 49.9 · Meta: provisional
  • Primary role: Removal / Negation · Secondary: Utility

Why it scores here

Black Return is a set Trap whose only job is to bounce one opponent face-up monster and gain LP equal to its ATK, and only when exactly one Blackwing monster is Special Summoned with no other monster. It is a tempo card rather than a card-advantage engine, so it earns modest interaction and economy points. Its presence in 16 of 16 sampled Blackwing-leaning decks confirms a real, practical role but does not raise the score on its own, and its high-ATK targets earn nothing extra beyond the LP gained.

Axis scores

Axis Score Evidence
Accessibility 55 Set in the backrow and drawn normally, but it only activates when a Blackwing is the sole monster Special Summoned, so it is conditionally live (deck data: 16 decks, 1.19 avg copies; text) (inferred).
Combo & Conversion 30 No recorded boards, so the card's conversion is text-only: it removes one board piece rather than building one (combo data: 0 appearances) (inferred).
Resource Economy 30 A bounce returns an opponent monster to hand, which costs them tempo rather than giving card advantage, and the LP gain is a small bonus (text) (inferred).
Effect & Interaction 55 Targets any face-up opponent monster and can be set and held, but the Blackwing-only single-summon trigger narrows when it is useful (text; deck data: 16/16 decks) (verified).
Material Utility 0 A Trap card cannot be used as material, so this axis scores zero (text) (verified).
Resilience & Flexibility 35 Once triggered the effect is resolved, and a set Trap can be negated by an opponent's interruption before it resolves; no redundancy beyond the copy count (text) (inferred).
Deck-Building Efficiency 60 Mostly one copy per deck with no garnet or lock, but it occupies a slot only useful in Blackwing-heavy builds (deck data: avg 1.19 copies, max 2) (observed).

Calculation

Weight profile: 0.7 Removal/Negation + 0.3 Utility. Intrinsic ≈ 45.6, Deck ≈ 49.9, Meta = provisional. Modifiers: none. Final formula: 0.40*Intrinsic + 0.60*Deck

Strengths

  • Cheap, low-garnet trap that fits Blackwing shells
  • Bounce plus LP gain gives tempo on a Special Summon turn
  • Appears in every sampled Blackwing-leaning deck, so its role is practical

Weaknesses

  • Activation needs exactly one Blackwing summoned with no other monster
  • No card advantage and no board-building
  • Text is archetype-locked, limiting use outside Blackwing

Counters / choke points

  • Opponent negation or trap interruption before resolution
  • Decks that Special Summon several monsters at once never meet the trigger

Best use

Single-copy backrow tempo trap that answers one opposing monster on a clean Blackwing Special Summon. Decks: Blackwings (archetype 187), Blackwings (archetype 628), Crimson Dragon. Suggested copies: 1.

Evidence & gaps

  • Verified: Trap card, Blackwing archetype (card); Bounces one face-up opponent monster and gains LP equal to its ATK (card text); Appears in 16 of 16 sampled decks (deck data)
  • Observed: Average 1.19 copies per deck, 13 decks at 1 copy and 3 at 2 (deck data); Blackwing Special Summon partners at 75–100% co-occurrence (deck data)
  • Inferred: Trigger condition limits practical activation to Blackwing-heavy boards; Bounce is tempo, not card advantage; Set-and-hold play is possible but an opponent negation can stop it
  • Data gaps: no combos supplied — combo conversion is text-only inference no banlist token — assumed 3 copies (unlimited) no usage statistics (StatisticsCard) — archetype inclusion % inferred from deck sample only no rulings supplied for the 'exactly 1 Blackwing and no other monster' trigger











https://metaduelist.com/
Top